New Jersey Court of Chancery July 15, 1836 (Richards v. West)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-07-1836

The Chancellor.

On" the fifteenth of August, eighteen hundred and thirty-five, an injunction bill was filed by Richards against West, and on the same day an injunction was issued, restraining West and his confederates from cutting, felling, removing, working up, or in any way interfering with, the timber, wood or trees, standing or lying on the premises mentioned and described in the said bill, or any part thereof, and from erecting any cabins or other buildings on the said premises, until answer and further order to the contrary.

On the twenty-ninth of October, eighteen hundred and thirty-five, the complainant applied for, and on producing sufficient affidavits obtained, a rule on the defendant to show cause why an attachment should not issue against him for disobeying the injunction. Under this rule a great mass of testimony has been taken, much of which is foreign to the issue.

The service of the injunction is proved; and it is clearly shown that a large quantity of wood has been cut, some of which has been coaled, and some carted away, since the injunction was served; and the attachment must go, unless the cause shown by the defendant shall be found sufficient to justify him before the court.

The main ground of justification is, that the’ cutting, which was continued at two different places, was not on any part of the “ West Jersey Society tract,” that being the name of the tract mentioned in the complainant’s bill, on which the trespass had been committed ; — That within the bounds of this large tract, *458there are a number of excepted and prior surveys, which are trot considered as forming a part of the tract; that the cutting after the service of the injunction was on some or one of these excepted surveys, and therefore not within the command of the writ. This defence is not set up by answer, under the oath of the party, (for no answer has been filed,) but by affidavits of witnesses and by documents produced before the master.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.