Tennessee Supreme Court December 15, 1836 (Smart v. Waterhose)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-12-1836

Creen, J.

delivered the opinion of the court.

The bill charges that Richard G. Waterhouse, late of Rhea county, made his will on 1st. February, 1827, and shortly afterwards departed this life, leaving Richard and Blaekstone his executors, to whom, and to the other defendants his children, and the complainant Elizabeth, he devised his estate. That the complainant, Elizabeth, who was the widow of the said Richard G., but has since intermarried with the complainant, William C. Smart, was not satisfied with the provis-on made for her in the said will, and determined to dissent therefrom within the time prescribed by law. The executors ascertaining her purpose, represented to her that her dissent would throw the whole estate into confusion and produce confusion among the other legatees, and therefore they wished that she would not dissent from the will. Richard Water-house, the oldest of the executors, represented to hor that the estate was not worth more than $40,000, and proposed to give her $5000, or her partin money, if she would change her determination. Being perplexed and not wishing to do any thing that would injure others, she accepted the proposition, and the executors promised to nay her the value of the property to which she would be entitled were she to dissent, and which they said would be about $5000, or that she might elect to take the $5000, or the value of the property when it could be ascertained. The agreement thus made was to be written out by Spencer Jarnagin Esq. as he was expected soon to pass by on his way to court. She was afterwards told that Mr. *99Jarnagin bad no time to do the writing and that he had passed by, but as new assurances were made to her, she confided in the fulfilment of the contract, and suffered the six months to elapse without dissenting.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.