Court of Appeals of Maryland December 15, 1837 (Harriett v. Ridgely)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-12-1837
Dorsey, Judge,
delivered the opinion of the court.
The proceedings in this case have been most irregularly conducted, and under any modification which has been given to them, it is difficult to conceive upon what grounds a successful result to the petitioner’s application could have been anticipated. The petition upon its face presents no such case as would have justified the interference of a court of justice, and either upon demurrer or suggestion to the court, it ought to have been dismissed. None of the provisions of the act of 1817, ch. 112, which have been relied on, can be invoked to the support of such a petition. Assuming the truth of all its statements, and the absence of all the other proof to be found in the record, and there is no law in this state which in such a case would warrant an interference with the rights of the slaveholder in executing the designs imputed to him by the petition.
As if foreseeing the utter inability of sustaining this petition under the act of 1817, on which it was predicated, the petitioner’s counsel promptly availed themselves of an opportunity afforded by the appellee, and join issue upon the peti*180tioner’s right to freedom — thus abandoning all the grounds assumed by the petition, and asserting a right wholly inconsistent with its allegations. The judgment of the court could not have been otherwise than against her, as conceding her to have been the absolute property of Mrs. -Dali, by the instrument of her emancipation, she was a slave for three years yet to come. But-supposing that obstacle to be removed, the decision of the court must have been the same. By the proof in the cause the'petitioner was not the slave of Mrs. Dali, and therefore derived no title to freedom under her will. But it is insisted that the appellee being the executor of Mrs. Dali, and having returned the petitioner as her slave in the inventory of her effects, is estopped from shewing that the appellant was the slave.of another.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit