Supreme Court of Vermont March 15, 1838 (Low v. Perkins)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-03-1838

The opinion of the Court was delivered by

Phelps, J.

This case, although somewhat complex, presents in reality but one question for our consideration. It appears that a contract had been entered into by the plaintiff, with certain individuals, as agents or trustees of an association for building a church, for erecting t'he building, upon certain specified terms; and in the course of the trial, it became necessary for the plaintiff to prove, that by agreement of parties the special contract was abandoned, and that he was to be paid for the erection of the building upon a quantum meruit.

*535To prove this, he offered testimony to prove that one of the agents had said to Morrison, who was associated with the plaintiff in the erection of the building, and to induce him to proceed with the work, that he should loose nothing if he proceeded with it-and, also, that another of the trustees had admitted, that such new contract was made. The case states that there were four or five of these trustees in all. The testimony was rejected by the court below, upon the ground that the concurrence of all the trustees was necessary, to alter the contract, to which the plaintiff excepted.

There can be no doubt that the court did right, in rejecting the testimony upon the ground stated. Where several individuals are associated in a public trust, it is competent for a majority to act, and to bind their principals ; but, in the case of a private trust or agency, the rule is different, and the concurrence of all is necessary. There is another reason why a part of this testimony was improper, and that is, that the testimony was hearsay only. It is a general rule, that the declarations of a person, who is himself a competent witness, shall not be received. I know of no exception to this rule, except when the declarations themselves are to be regarded as facts, and constitute a part of the res gesta.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.