Mississippi Supreme Court January 15, 1838 (Peyton v. Scott)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-01-1838
Mr. Chief Justice Shakeev
delivered the opinion of the court.
This action was instituted by Scott, against Hall, Buckner, Harris, Ephraim G-. Peyton and Thomas Haliday on a joint and several promissory note. Peyton and Haliday pleaded severally non assumpsit, and a verdict was found against them. Harris failed to plead and a judgment by default was taken against him, but before judgment against the others, a nolle prosequi was entered as to Hall.
It is urged for the plaintiffs in error, that the court erred in permitting the nolle prosequi to be entered as to Plall, and in afterwards proceeding to judgment against the others on the ground that the nolle prosequi was a discontinuance as to all the defendants. This appears to be the settled law, when the contract on which the action is founded is joint, but there is a marked difference when the contract is joint and several; for in such cases any or either of the obligors may be sued separately and no advantage can be taken of the non-joinder of the co-obli-gors, whereas if the contract were purely joint, the non-joinder would be fatal on a plea in abatement. If a party can sue the *872makers of a note separately, there can be no reason why he may not discontinue as to part of them after suit brought. This has been the constant practice in this state, and being one of convenience and utility in promoting the ends of justice, should not be interrupted, unless repugnant to some known principle of law.
But it is not the practice of this state alone. It is clearly deducible from the principles laid down in a note in 1 Saunders’s Rep. 207, note 2, and the case of Minor et al. v. The Mechanics’ Bank of Alexandria, 1 Peters’s S. C. Rep. 46, is directly in point. Four ■of the defendants pleaded separately and a nolle prosequi was entered as to the fifth, and held not to be error, even after judgment against those who had pleaded separately.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit