New York Supreme Court June 15, 1839 (People ex rel. Lyndes v. Comptroller of the State)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-06-1839

By the Court, Nelson, Ch. J.

If the commissioners are to be regarded as holding an office within the constitutional meaning of the term, there can be no reasonable doubt of the existence of the competent power to remove them. The 16th § of the 4th article of the constitution provides, that “ where the duration of any office is not prescribed by the constitution, it may be declared by law j and if not so declared, such office shall be held during the pleasure of the authority making the appointment.” The duration of office here obviously refers to the period of time the incumbent shall hold, that being the proper measure of it. This period had been previously prescribed in the constitution in *598respect to many of the offices ; and the scope of the section is to provide for the case of officers whose term of office is left at large, as well those that might be created by statute, as those to be found in the constitution. That the provision applies to the former, is apparent from the 15th § of the same article of the constitution, which provides for the election or appointment of all officers thereafter to be created by law, who it is but reasonable to conclude were, among others, intended to be referred to, and regulated by the succeeding section, as they come fairly both within its reason and general terms.

Assuming, then, that the commissioners are to be regarded as holding an office, which I am inclined to think they should he, within the intent of the legislature, being recognized as such twice in the statute, § 5 and 9, it is clear, according to the above exposition, as there is no fixed period of time during which they are to hold, they are removable at the pleasure of the appointing power ; and as that power is vested in the governor, secretary of state, and comptroller, for the time being, they are removable by them.

But even if we were to reject the idea that the commissioners hold an office, the result must necessarily be the same.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.