Ohio Supreme Court December 15, 1840 (Young v. Miller)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-12-1840
Wood, J.
The case, it will be seen, is presented, by the pleadings, with the parties directly at issue on every material point which constitutes the gist of the complaint. The onus probandi lies, therefore, on the complainant, and the maxim, secundum allegata et probata, adapts itself to every jurisdiction, and to every civil action. Keeping these familiar principles in view, the proofs must be first applied, and then comes in the law, which sweeps away the foundation on which the structure rests, o.' it extends tho’ *89relief, which its wisdom has provided, as peculiarly adapted to the individual ease.
The complainant states that, in 1816, Hargraves and wife rented him the ground in controversy, during the life of the feme. That he entered and occupied until 1834, when he was dispossessed by Worthington. Hargraves, it appears, was seized in right of his wife, the lot being set off to her, as her right of dower, in the estate of Cutler. From the face of the pleadings, the question then arises, why is Young, the complainant, in this court? Having the right of possession, why did he not defend under his lease, in the ejectment brought against him by Worthington? For in ejectment there is no right of action, unless there is a right also of possession, which may be delivered under an habere facias possessionem. This is, however, explained by an inspection of the lease, an exhibit in the case, from which it appears not to have been acknowledged nor accompanied with a separate examination, and being executed by a feme covert, it passed to the lessee nothing but a freehold for the life of the husband, who died in February, 1833. Worthington v. Young, 6 Ohio, 313.
The rights of the complainant ceased, therefore, by the expiration of his term, with the death of Hargraves, and after that period he was a mere tenant by sufferance, and liable to be evicted by Worthington.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit