Supreme Court of North Carolina June 5, 1841 (Fortescue v. . Satterthwaite)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-06-1841

Daniel, J.

This an action of trover for the conversion of three slaves. Pleas, The

general issue

and

release.

Willi-Satterthwaite in the year 1813 bequeathed legacies to each of his three children, James, Nancy, and Sally. The testator, after making several other devises and bequests in his will, then proceeds and says, “In case either of my said children should die without heir lawfully begotten, it is my wish that-the property should be equally divided between the children

then

living, whether James, Nancy or Sally.” The said three children were alive at the death of their father. Afterwards James first died; Nancy then died without issue (in July, 1836,) leaving Sally the only survivor. The slaves in controvercy were a part of those bequeathed to Nancy as aforesaid. Sally had married the plaintiff Fortescue; and she and her husband on the 27th January, 1834, executed to the defendant, then in possession, the deed for the said slaves, marked in this case with the letter (D.) Sally, the plaintiff’s wife, died, and he, as her administrator, has brought this action. The Judge was of opinion, that the contingent interest or executory devise, which each one of these children had in the legacies to the other children, was not too remote; but that the words

“then

living,

whether

James,

Nancy or

Sally” tied up the contingency to the death of the first taker without issue. But the Judge refused to permit the aforementioned deed from the plaintiff to the defendant to be received in evidence. The plaintiff had a verdict and judgment, and the defendant appealed.

We agree with the Judge that, in this case, the limitation over to Sally, the survivor, of the legacy given to Nancy, on her dying without issue, was not too remote; but-that it was

*570

a good executory devise. The meaning of the testator is plain, that on any one or two of the children dying without f ’ , J . , ,. .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.