Supreme Court of Pennsylvania September 15, 1841 (Gray v. Monongahela Navigation Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-09-1841

The opinion of the Court was delivered by

Gibson, C. J.

It has long been settled by decision and practice, that the copy of the laws published annually by the authority of the legislature, is evidence of the statutes contained in it, whether they be public or private; and this disposes of the first bill of exceptions to evidence.

The second brings up the only material point in the cause; but the exception cannot be sustained. A grant of additional privi*160leges to a corporation, has certainly not been thought an invasion of the contract which exists between it and subscribers to its stock. It is alleged to be so, in this instance, because the grant of a privilege to raise the dams higher than was allowed by the original Act, might lead to a greater expenditure to compensate injuries to the riparian owners by flooding their lands, than was contemplated when the defendant became a stockholder. But what was there in the contract of subscription to forbid the acceptance of such a grant ? The contract remains unchanged by it, though its consequences may be varied: it was to pay so much the share, and so it is yet. But the constitutional restriction of the power of the states to enact laws which impair the obligation of a contract, has regard to direct, and not consequential invasions of it. Thus in Mason v. Haile, (12 Wheat. 370), it was considered that a state has a right to regulate or abolish imprisonment for debt as a part of the remedy for enforcing a debt, though by doing so it undoubtedly takes away one of-the incidental advantages of the contract which may have been in the view of the creditor when he entered into it. So also in Watson v. Mercer, (8 Peters 88), an Act to confirm a title imperfect under the recording laws, was held good. That Act, however, tended more properly to establish the obligation of a contract than to impair it; yet it certainly varied the consequences of the contract, such as it was. In The Providence Bank v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.