Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Philadelphia County January 16, 1841 (Buckley v. Handy)
Also known as
United States · · · 16-01-1841
lead-opinion
Jones, J.—
Several reasons for a new trial have been urged in this case, some of which are founded upon the form of the verdict, and others upon the form of the pleadings, and the evidence admissible under the pleadings, as well as upon the merits of the case.
The defendant pleaded five pleas, viz. non cepit; property in himself; property in Jennings & Craige; property in Robert A. Parrish; and that the property was in the possession of the sheriff under execution.
As to the last three of these pleas, the jury were told (in substance), that there was no evidence on the part of the defendant to support them. They were also instructed that the defendant’s defence, if it could avail him at all, must avail him under the pleas of non cepit and property in himself. This however was not so much a matter of direction to the jury, as an intimation to the counsel, and the observation was made with a reservation of the question for the consideration of the whole court.
The jury were specially charged to inquire into the facts, controverted between the parties, viz. whether the defendant had notice, before the time of his advance to Jennings & Craige, that they were not the actual owners of the merchandise in question, and whether the defendant had not, according to the evidence in the cause, waived his lien for his advances.
The question of law therefore is fairly brought up for decision. I shall in the first place notice the questions raised upon the pleadings.
The authorities are clear that the plea of non cepit controverts all the material averments in the declaration, excepting that *454which affirms that the goods mentioned are the goods of the plaintiffs. The terms of this plea are sufficiently broad to comprehend the question of property, and according to the analogy of the actions of trespass and detinue, it would seem, that the defendant should be allowed to show under this plea that the goods taken were not the goods of the plaintiffs.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit