Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court September 15, 1841 (Putney v. Dresser)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-09-1841
Dewey, J.
The defendant insists that the action of trespass quare clausum will not lie upon the facts stated in this case. The position assumed is, that as to a moiety of the estate in the premises upon which the trespass is alleged to have been committed, the plaintiff’s right of entry was tolled.
By the principles of the common law, modified by the St. of 32 Hen. VIII. c. 33, and which were adopted and recognized, as a part of our legal code, until superseded by the enactment in the Rev. Sts. c. 101, § 5, if a disseizor had been in the peaceable possession of land, as such disseizor, for the space of fiva *586years next after the disseizin, and should die thus seized, and his estate descend to his heirs at law, it would bar the right of entry of the disseizee.
The defendant contends that the disseizin in 1818, by Moses Dresser and Aaron Dresser, the grantees in the deed from Moses Putney, was not a joint disseizin, or one which would create a joint tenancy in them, but only an estate as tenants in common. It is true that under St. 1785, c. 62,' the title in Moses Dresser and Aaron Dresser, if any had passed to them under their deed from Moses Putney, would have been an estate in common, and not in joint tenancy. But no title passed to them under that deed, their grantee having no title and no right to convey. As respects the plaintiffs, they were strictly disseizors, and as much so as if they had entered without receiving any deed. The inquiry then arises as to the effect of a disseizin by two or more persons. Littleton, § 278, says, “ if tw_. or three disseize another of any lands or tenements to their own use, then the disseizors are joint tenants.” There may be, therefore, a joint tenancy created by disseizin, as well as by a deed or devise. The St. of 1785, c. 62, applies only to cases arising under deeds and wills, leaving the cases of disseizin to be regulated by the common law.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit