Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court September 15, 1841 (Bacon v. Bowdoin)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-09-1841

Wilde, J.

This case came on to be heard on the bill and answer, and on an agreed statement of facts, many of which, according to the view we have taken of the law and equity of the case, are wholly immaterial.

The principal question on which the decision of the case depends is, whether the property, demised by Shaw to the plaintiff, was real or personal estate. This question and several others, not now .contested, have been determined at a former hearing, on demurrer to the bill. 22 Pick. 401. But the defendants’ counsel now contend, that upon the facts agreed a different decision is required.

It is now agreed by the parties, that the building leased to the plaintiff was first erected by one Billings, he having no title to the land on which it was erected, and that the same was erected with the permission of Bowdoin, one of the defendants, and one Lewis, who were the owners of the land, to be used by Billings as a blacksmith’s shop. That this shop was by sundry conveyances finally sold to Joshua Shaw, the plaintiff’s lessor, as per sonal property. And from these facts, it is inferred by the defendants’ counsel, that the said Shaw so leased it to the plaintiff But we are of the opinion that this inference cannot be sustained, and that the lease cannot be so construed. By the conveyance of the building to Shaw, it became attached to the real estate. A large addition was made to it by him, before he leased it to the plaintiff. The building was not then completed ; but Shaw in the lease covenanted to complete the same, and to complete it in such a manner as to render it suitable for the manufacturing *598of cotton and other articles, and that he would put in a waterwheel and machinery suitable for this purpose. In pursuance of this covenant and agreement, Shaw put a new water-wheel into said building, and erected a new doom before the time limited for the commencement of the lease.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.