Supreme Court of Alabama January 15, 1841 (Bartlett v. Lang)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-01-1841

COLLIER, C. J.

— The demurrer of the defendants was superseded by the pleas, on which issues were tried by the jury; so that the inquiry in the Court below was not, whether the declaration disclosed a good cause of action, but did the proof offered by the plaintiffs, tend to sustain its allegations. The defendant’s pleas impliedly admitted that the declaration set forth in a legal manner, a state of facts, which, if true, entitled the plaintiffs to recover; but denied their truth and called for the proof. If the declaration was so palpably defective, as not to sustain a recovery, the defendant might ha ve availed herself of the defects, on a motion in arrest of judgment, or on error; but it was not competent for the Court to exclude from the jury evidence (otherwise unexceptionable,) which went to prove or disprove the respective averments of the parties.

Now the several matters which the plaintiffs proposed to prove to the jury, viz : the note described in the first and second counts of the declaration; the protest thereof; and due notice of protest to each of the partners of the firm of McRae and Lang — that McRae & Lang were partners, and that the .endoTS'ément of the note was made by the former, in the pre-seiie^of,and with the assent of the latter, &c. — were clearly within'thf terms of the issues. And even if the action was not mainffuAa'jble, as that question was not raised, the evidence should no? have been rejected.

■ Bdt%jfhout pretending to inquire whether any, or which of ttje-ccmlnts of the declaration are defective; we are satisfied it was competent for the plaintiffs, by following the directions of the act referred to, by the Judge of the Circuit Court, in his charge to the jury, to maintain an action against the representatives of a deceased partner, upon an endorsement made by partners previous to its passage.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.