Supreme Court of Vermont January 15, 1841 (Parks v. Moore)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-01-1841
The opinion of the court wag delivered by
Collamer, J.
An adjudication on the merits of a cause, by a court of competent jurisdiction, is conclusive of the matter litigated, upon the parties, and all claiming under them ; and, by our statute, a judgment in ejectment is conclusive of title. The identity of the subject matter of litigation, however, generally rests in parol. It is seldom the case that this can be settled by the record alone, as it may be avoided by a different description. When the declaration is of a general character, as in'general indebitatus as-< sumpsii, though the judgment is, prima facie, conclusive of all that might have been given in evidence under it, yet, resort may be had to evidence to show what, in fact, was litigated, and of that, only, will the judgment be conclusive. This the plaintiff or defendant may be permitted to do. So, too, the prima facie effect of a judgment may be qualified, even in ejectment, by showing, by parol, that the title was not, in fact, litigated ; or by. showing that the judgment was against the plaintiff; not on the title, but because he did not prove that the defendant was in possession, or because the defendant showed a temporary estate or right in himself, which has since expired. That the identity of the subject matter of a former action, and the present one, rests, generally, in evidence out of the record, and that parol testimony may be admitted to ascertain it, is quite obvious, and fully settled by the authorities cited by the defendant’s counsel, in this case. To this point, the jurors, on the former trial,, are as admissible as any other witnesses. They were witnesses to show that the land now sued for, and of which the defendant is in possession, is, in fact, the same land, which, perhaps, under a different description, was claimed and litigated in the former suit.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit