Illinois Supreme Court December 15, 1841 (President, Directors, & Co. of the State Bank v. Aersten)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-12-1841
Treat, Justice,
delivered the opinion of the Court-:
This was an action of assumpsit, brought by the appellees against the appellants. The declaration alleges that the appellees were the bona fide holders of a bank note made by the appellants, of the denomination of $100, (setting out the date and number, and particularly describing the note); that the note was divided by the appellees, into two parts, for the purpose of being transmitted by mail; that the agent of the appellees put the right hand half of the note into the postoffice at Charleston, Illinois, enclosed in a letter directed to the appellees, at Philadelphia ; which letter, with the enclosure of the half note, was never received by them, but was lost; and that the appellees presented the left hand half to the appellants, demanding payment of the note, which was refused. •
The appellants demurred to the declaration, and the Court overruled the demurrer. The appellants abiding by their demurrer, the Court rendered judgment against them for the amount of the note. An appeal is prosecuted to this Court, and the appellants assign for error, the decision, of the Court in overruling the demurrer to the declaration.
The question for determination is, can the holder of a bank note, who has divided it for the purpose of transmission by mail, and has lost one half, recover of the maker the amount of the note, upon presentation of the other half ?
The rightful owner of a note or bill negotiable by delivery, cannot recover of the maker or acceptor, upon proof that it has been lost or stolen, for it may get into the hands of a third person, for a good consideration, and without any notice of the loss or larceny, who would be entitled to recover of the maker or acceptor, on the ground that if one of two innocent persons is to suffer, it should be the one who has occasioned the loss or injury.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit