Indiana Supreme Court November 15, 1841 (Sanders v. Johnson)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-11-1841
Dewey, J.
Johnsoti sued Sanders in slander for charging him with perjury. The defendant pleaded, 1, The general issue, which, after two continuances from term to term, lu withdrew; 2, The statute of limitations, upon the traverse of which there was issue; 3, Three pleas of justification, alleging as many distinct instances of perjury against the plaintiff, committed on different occasions. De injuria replied to each of these pleas, and issues formed thereon. After a part of the jury was sworn, the defendant asked leave of the Court to withdraw the plea of the statute of limitations; leave was refused. When the trial commenced both parties claimed the right to begin with the testimony, and to make the opening *55argument. The Court awarded it to the plaintiff. At the time of swearing his witnesses, and before they were examined, the defendant moved the Court to remove such witnesses as the plaintiff still held in reserve, so that they might not hear the defendant’s witnesses. The motion was overruled. The Court suppressed one of the defendant’s depositions, but another deposition, made by the same witness and containing the same matter as that rejected, was read to the jury by the defendant. The defendant offered to prove, in mitigation of damages, that the same charge laid in the declaration had been reported by others against the plaintiff before the defendant made it. The testimony was rejected. The defendant moved the Court to give several instructions to the jury, which, so far as they were pertinent to the issues, were given, with the •exception of the following, viz.: “If the circumstances proved in the cause create a suspicion that the plaintiff committed perjury, but do not amount to proof of his guilt, the jury *shoidd consider them in mitigation of the damages.” This charge the Court refused. The jury found a verdict for the plaintiff, and assessed his damages at $2,736. A motion for a new trial was overruled, and final judgment rendered upon the verdict.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit