Court of Appeals of Kentucky October 20, 1841 (Lougee v. Colton)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-10-1841

lead-opinion

Chief Justice Robertson

delivered the Opinion of the Court.

As there was a joint demurrer to the three several pleas to the landlords avowry of distress for rent, the demurrer was properly overruled, if either of those pleas be good.

1. The first and third pleas are substantially the same: that is, that when the distress was made, the term having expired, the relation of landlord and tenant had ceased, the landlord was in possession^ and the distrained goods were not on the demised premises.

2. There is nothing in any or all of these facts, as pleaded, which can avoid the avowry. At common law the landlord could not distrain after the expiration of the term, nor at any other place than on the demised premises, nor after the tenant had left those premises.

3. The Virginia Statute of 1748, still viewing distress for rent as a real and local remedy arising from privity of estate—in providing for distress, after the end of the term, still required that it should be made whilst the tenant was in possession. But since the enactment of the Kentucky Statute of 1811, the right to distrain for rent is not limited by the tenant’s possession: no reason remains for such a restriction, which might be altogether subversive of the end and policy of this remedial statute, the first section of which authorizes distress in any county *116to which -the tenant shall have removed himself and property, and a fortiori must be construed as intending a distress any where in the county of the demised premises after the tenant’s removal of himself and effects from those premises.

To avoid the avowry of distress for rent, a plea strictly denying any, rent in arrear, is necessary; to say that the tenant was not indebted the rents in the avowry mentioned, without denying that any was clue, is not good.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.