Tennessee Supreme Court April 15, 1841 (Booker v. Tally)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-04-1841
Green, J.
delivered the opinion of the court.
This is an action of assumpsit brought by Tally against Booker & Clarkson, to which they pleaded the amount of an account for goods sold and delivered, as an offset to plaintiff’s demand.
It appeared in evidence that articles charged in the account to amount of *$60 were delivered to Wm. Tally, jr., a son of the plaintiff, over the age of 31 years. William, jr. had no credit at the store of defendants, and he procured the goods directing them tobe charged to his father, which was done at the time. Other sons and sons-in-law were in the habit of getting goods upon the plaintiff’s account.
When William, jr. was about to remove from the country, the clerk in defendants’ store called on the plaintiff and told him that some of the articles in his account had been gotten by his son William; whereupon the plaintiff said the defendants were right in charging the goods to him, and that he would pay for them. The court charged the jury that, “If the plaintiff in the first instance *310did not direct the defendants to charge the articles to him, he would not be bound to pay for them unless the promise to do so had been reduced to writing.”
The jury returned a verdict in favor of the plaintiff disallowing the articles charged to him, and which had been delivered to his son William. The defendants moved for a new trial which was refused, and judgment was rendered on the verdict of the jury, from which judgment this appeal in error is taken.
We think the court erred in the charge to the jury. His Honor overlooked the distinction between where the credit is given in the first instance to the party receiving the goods, and the case where no such credit is given, but the goods were delivered on account of the person sought to be charged. In the former case the charge of the court would be correct; for the delivery of the goods to A.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit