Tennessee Supreme Court December 15, 1841 (Dains v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-12-1841

Green, J.

delivered the opinion of the court.

The plaintiff in error was indicted in the circuit court of Dickson county, for an assault and battery upon John J. Allbright with intent “unlawfully, maliciously and with premeditation to kill and *440murder.” He was found guilty by the jury, and sentenced to seven years imprisonment'in the penitentiary. A new trial was moved for and- refused, and the defendant appealed to this court.

From the evidence in the cause, as it is set forth in this record, it appears, that the defendant and the prosecutor, Allbright, with others, were engaged on the day of the assault, at work, raising a house. In the evening the defendant had a fall from the house on which they had been working, and while down, Allbright jocosely jumped upon him, and called for a lancet to bleed him. Some time after this, the defendant stepped up to the place where Allbright was setting on a log, and “punched” him in the side. Allbright said “dont Dains, you hurt me,” upon which Dains desisted. Soon after this, and between sunset and dark, Dains stepped to get his axe, with which he had worked all day, and then with his axe upon his shoulder, walked to the table where the liquors were kept, with Allbright, he having invited Allbright to drink with him.

When they got to the table, Dains called for a glass of cider: Allbright said he wanted stronger drink than cider, and while Dains was drinking his cider, Allbright went behind him and “hunched” him with his knee, so that the cider was spilled over him, when Dains said “dont do that again,” on which Allbright slapped him on the shoulder, and Dains struck a violent blow with the axe upon the side of AUbright’s head, and knocked him. down, giving him a dangerous wound. The parties had been drinking somewhat during the day, but had no quarrel, and were previously friendly.

This indictment is framed upon the 53d section of the act of 1829, ch.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.