Tennessee Supreme Court December 15, 1841 (Caplinger v. Sullivan)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-12-1841
Reese, J.
delivered the opinion of the court.
This is an action of detinue for slaves. The property in question was bequeathed by the last will and testament of Boling Felts-to his wife, for life, and after her death to Ann Sullivan, the plaintiff in this suit, then the wife of William Sullivan, and the said William was appointed executor of the will. He duly took upon himself that office, and in 1819, purchased of Mary Felts, testator’s-widow, the property in- question, for the sum of one hundred dollars per annum, to be paid to her during her life.
In 1830, Mary Felts acknowledged in writing her reception of a sum in gross, from William Sullivan, in satisfaction of her annuity. Subsequently, in-the same year, William Sullivan conveyed the slaves, for a valuable consideration, to Caplinger, the defendant, and put him in possession thereof, he, himself, having been possessed of them from the time- of his purchase in-1819. William Sullivan died in 1835. Mary Felts, the owner of the slaves for life, and Ann Sullivan, the wife of William, to whom they were limited in remainder, surviving. Mary Felts died in 1838.
These facts, in the circuit court, were found by the jury in a; special verdict, and judgment thereon was pronounced by his honor *549the circuit judge, in favor of Ann Sullivan, the plaintiff, and the defendant, Caplinger, has appealed in error to this court.
Justice Story, in his Commentaries on Equity, paragraph 1413, states it as a principle, that “no assignment by the husband, of re-versionary choses in action, pr other reversionary equitable interests of the wife, even with her consent and joining in the assignment, will exclude her right of survivorship.” The assignment, he adds, “is not, and cannot from the nature of the thing, amount to a reduction into possession of such reversionary interests.”
The general principle thus laid down, we find to be abundantly sustained by authority, and particularly, by the leading cases on the subject, Purdew vs.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit