Supreme Court of New Jersey November 15, 1841 (Mann v. Drost)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-11-1841

Nevius, J.

The case presented by the parties, shows, that one Garret Van Middlesworth made an assignment to the plaintiff in Certiorari, for the benefit of creditors, in August, 1836. That in January, 1837, the claimant Drost, filed with the assignee, a claim of four hundred and eighty-seven dollars and thirty-eight cents, on a promissory note dated the 17th June, 1836, and payable on demand for that sum, to which he annexed an affidavit, that the same was justly due to him from Van Middlesworth.

To this claim, the assignee filed exceptions, which pursuant to the provisions of the sixth section of the said act, came on to be heard before a jury at the Somerset Pleas in the term of June, 1839. Before the jury were sworn, the assignee objected to the hearing of the ease, and produced the record of a judgment in the same court, against Van Middlesworth and in favor of Drost, dated the 18th June, 1836, for four hundred and eighty-seven dollars and thirty-seven cents, being a judgment by confession *337on the same note, and which was afterwards filed as a claim with the assignee : and also an order of the said court of Common Pleas, in October term, 1836, setting aside said judgment, on the ground of fraud and want of consideration in the note; and thereupon prayed that the claim be dismissed, and the jury discharged. The court refused to do so, and directed the jury to be sworn.

The jury rendered a verdict for the claimant for four hundred and thirty-three dollars. To set aside these proceedings, this Certiorari is brought.

The counsel for the defendant have raised several preliminary questions.

First, That a Certiorari could only be brought in this case, either before issue joined, or after a final adjudication by the court. That this Certiorari was presented after issue and before any such final judgment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.