Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court October 15, 1842 (Claflin v. Carpenter)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-10-1842

Wilde, J.

This case comes before us on exceptions to the instructions of the court of common pleas to the jury, as to the construction and legal effect of a mortgage deed from one McDavit, from which the plaintiffs claim title to the properly sued for. By the report of the case, it appears that on the 1st of September 1840, the plaintiffs sold to the said McDavit a quantity of wood and timber then on their land, part of which was then cut and lying on their land, and part was uncut and *582standing on the said land. And on the same day the said McDavit gave a mortgage deed to the plaintiffs of all said wood and timber, cut and uncut.

On these facts, the jury were instructed that the timber, which was uncut at the time of making said mortgage, was real estate, and that it was incumbent on the plaintiffs, in order to entitle them to a verdict, to prove that the timber sued for in this action had been cut and severed from the freehold, at the time when said mortgage was given. To these instructions the plaintiffs’ counsel excepts, and he contends that the said mortgage was a contract for the sale of wood and timber, and not for the sale of lands, or any interest therein. That such a sale was intended by the contracting parties we cannot doubt; and the question is, whether by the principles of law the intention of the parties can be effectuated.

In a leading case on this point, 1 Ld. Raym. 182, it was reported by Treby, C. J. to the other justices, that it was decided by him at nisi prius, that the sale of timber growing on land might be by parol, and was not by the statute of frauds required to be in writing ; and to the correctness of this decision Powell, J. agreed. This decision is cited as an authority in Bul. N. P. 282, and by Holroyd, J. in Mayfield v. Wadsley 3 Barn. & Cres. 364.

In Scorell v. Boxall, 1 Younge & Jerv. 399, Hullock, B. remarked, that he never before heard the dictum in Ld. Raym.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.