Supreme Court of Connecticut July 15, 1843 (Burgess v. Tweedy)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-07-1843
Williams, Ch. J.
The plaintiff in error claims, that he is aggrieved by the judgment of a justice of the peace, of which he had no notice, actual or legal; and that this is the only way known to our practice to avoid it. The defendants in error say, that the error assigned is on the face of the record, and directly impeaches it; which cannot be done; in support *43of which they cite the case of Molins v. Wetby, 1 Lev. 76. The principle, as claimed by the defendants, is correct, and is supported by numerous authorities besides the case cited. Helbut v Held, 2 Ld. Ray. 1414. S. C. 1 Stra. 684. Bradburn v. Taylor, 1 Wils. 85. Wetmore v. Plant, in this court, 5 Conn. R. 541. The question, however, is, do these authorities apply to this case? In the case from Levins, there was a judgment purporting to be rendered by the duke of Ormond, in his court; and the error assigned was, that the duke was not present; [—the object was to try whether his duty could be discharged by deputy;] and the court held, that the absence of the duke could not be assigned for error, it being contrary to the record. And nothing is more clear, than that it was so; for the record alleged, that the judgment was before James, duke of Ormond. In this case, the record alleges, that the justice was present, on the 7th day of August, and adjourned the hearing to the 14th of August. The writ of error alleges, that Burgess attended, on the 7th of August, from 9 o’clock until after 10 o’clock, and the justice did not appear. But it is not alleged or claimed, that the justice was not present on the 7th day—only that he was not present from 9 o’clock until after 10, when the defendant attended. The facts thus stated in the record and in the writ of error are entirely consistent with each other; and as both may be true, we cannot say that one contradicts the other.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit