Supreme Court of Louisiana October 15, 1843 (Pinckney v. Mulhollan)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-10-1843
Simon, J.
The defendant is appellant from a judgment which condemns him to pay to the plaintiff the sum of $500, the amount of a note drawn by him, and made payable to the order of J. B, Scott, and his wife Caroline L. Scott, the present plaintiff, and endorsed over to the latter by the syndic of J. B, Scott’s insolvent estate.
The defence set up is, that the defendant has fully paid and extinguished said note ; that after having paid it, he repeatedly called upon'J. B, Scott to deliver up said note, which Scott always promised to do, alleging as the cause of not doing so, that he had mislaid it; but that he, said defendant, has never been able to get it from Scott.
Interrogatories were propounded by the plaintiff to the defendant, the answers to which show, that the note sued on was given in part consideration of the price of a plantation, of which a donation was made to the plaintiff by one 'William Miller ; that the *42defendant paid J. B. Scott the amount of the note, one year after its date ; and that Scott promised to Jeave said note with B. Chew, for which Chew was to give a note he held of said Scott in exchange, &c.
The evidence further shows, that after Scott’s death, the note was found to be in the hands of the plaintiff; that it was not found among the papers of the deceased; and that it was subsequently presented for payment by the plaintiff to the defendant, who said he had paid it, but that after being told that the note was a debt due to Caroline L. Scott, and could not be offset, or compensated by a debt due by J. B. Scott, the defendant promised to pay it. Several other facts have been disclosed in support of the plea of payment, which it is unnecessary to notice.
The evidence shows, in substance, that the note sued on was the paraphernal property of the plaintiff; and no proof has been adduced that it ever was in the possession, or under the control of her husband at any time after it was executed.
We think the District Judge did not err.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit