Supreme Court of North Carolina December 5, 1844 (Waddy v. . Johnson)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-12-1844
Gaston, J.
It is not very clear, upon the allegation in the petition, whether the complaint of injury, therein set forth, to the health of the petitioner’s family, because of the miasma and other noxious exhalations, arising from the stagnant water of the defendant’s pond, is a substantive distinct gravamen, independent of the complaint, that the petitioner’s land has been overflowed by the waters ofthe defendant’s pond — or is brought forward as a further and incidental injury, consequent upon the wrong of overflowing the petitioner’s land. If we were
*335
bound to regard it in the latter point of view, we should be obliged to hold the instruction of his Honor, herein set forth, erroneous ; for supposing the petitioner’s land not overflowed by the defendant’s porid, the wrong complained of did not exist.
Bridges
v.
Purcell,
1 Ired. 232. But the petition may be understood as charging two wrongs distinct from each other, whereof one might exist and not the other, viz: that the defendant’s dam threw back the water of his pond upon the petitioner’s land, and, also, that the stagnant water of the defendant’s pond injuriously affected the health of the petitioner’s family. If the petition can be thus interpreted, the instruction complained of brings directly before us a question, which we feel to be not free from difficulty, which has more than once been the subject of conference amongst us, and on which we have heretofore sedulously abstained from pronouncing, because heretofore it has not been necessary to pronounce, any authoritative opinion.
The 74th chapter of the revised statutes on “mills and millers,” puts together in a condensed form all the enactments, contained in the acts of 1809, ch, 773; 1813, ch. 863, and of 1833, ch. 6. In describing “ the person,” authorised and directed to
prosecute his
complaint in the manner herein prescribed, the language of the legislature is very broad.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit