Ohio Supreme Court December 15, 1844 (Northern Bank of Kentucky v. Roosa)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-12-1844
Birchard, J.
Two questions arise in this case:
1, Are judgments liens upon permanent leasehold estates for onoyear ?
2. Can one judgment, by a levy upon lands within ten days, obtain a preference over other judgments rendered at the same time, and levied within the year?
The solution of the first question depends upon the correctnossof an opinion of this court, reported in Loring v. Melendy, 11 Ohio, 357. The opinion alluded to, was upon a point not necessary to the determination of the cause, and not considered by all the-members of the court at the time. Hence the remark made in the case of Lessee of Boyd v. Talbert, 12 Ohio, 213, “the question whether a lease be realty or personalty,” is open. This case brings the subject fairly before us, and is the point upon which the decision must turn.
It is not doubted that at common law, leasehold estates wore but chattel interests. Upon the death of the owner, they vested in *315the executor, or administrator, and not in the heir, and were subject, to the debts of' the decedent as chattels.
Adjudications upon these points had been so frequent that, after the reason of the rule had ceased, courts, whose office is to declare the law, not to create it, felt bound by the numerous decisions; and the common law, in this respect, was the law of Ohio, until modified by legislative enactment. Thus in Bisbee’s Lessee v. Hall, 3 Ohio 449, it was held that a lease for ninety-nine years was liable to execution as a chattel. And in Reynolds v. Commissioners of Stark County, 5 Ohio, 204, that a lease ior ninety-nine years, renewable forever, was personal ^property, which, on the owner’s decease, went to the executor.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit