Tennessee Supreme Court December 15, 1844 (White v. Harris)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-12-1844
Tueley, J.
delivered tbe opinion of the court.
Archibald C. White recovered several judgments before a .Justice of the Peace for Giles county,,on the 7th day of February, 1842, against William Brown and Ira E. Brown, upon notes in which Ira E. Brown was surety for William Brown: these 'judgments were stayed by Robert S. Harris, without having been requested so to do by Ira E. Brown the surety. After the expiration of the time for which the judgments were thus stayed, executions were issued thereon, and levied on the property of the defendant Robert S. Harris, William Brown being insolvent, and IraE. Brown claiming protection as surety, upon the ground that tbe judgments were stayed by the defendant at the sole request of William Brown. Defendant filed ■ his petition for a writ of supersedeas, alledging.that he had stayed the executions at the request of Ira E. Brown: he afterwards amended his petition, and charged that the contracts upon which the judgments were rendered were usurious. A jury was impanneled in the Circuit Court to try the matter in dispute between the parties to the petition, viz, the present plaintiff and defendant; and the defendant, as we suppose, having-failed to prove that he stayed the judgments at the request of Ira-E. Brown, as well as of William Brown, the only matter submitted to the jury, was upon thf? question of usury. Under the charge of the Judge, a verdict was found in favor of the *422plaintiff', for the amount of $588 debt, and $100 44 damages for the detention; being less by twenty per cent, than the amount called for in the notes, that being the amount of discount at which plaintiff purchased them. The usury is controverted in the proof; but we do not deem it necessary to enter into an investigation of the question, nor into the accuracy of the opinion and charge of the Judge, as we are well satisfied that the defendant Harris could not legally make this defence in this mode of proceeding.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit