Supreme Court of Alabama June 15, 1845 (Hayden v. Boyd)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-06-1845

COLLIER, C. J.

It is enacted by the act of 1839, that “in all suits to be commenced upon accounts for a sum not exceeding one hundred dollars, the oath of the plaintiff shall be received as evidence of the demand, unless the same be controverted by the oath of the defendant; but this section shall not apply to the case of executors and administrators, trustees and guardians, when sued.” (Clay’s Dig. 342, § 161.]

Under the act of 1819, which permits the borrower of money to prove that a usurious rate of interest was reserved, unless the lender will deny on oath the truth of his testimony, it has been held, that he could not be sworn and examined as a witness generally. And where the record affirms that he was offered as a witness, without stating the object, if there was a defence other than usury set up, it cannot be intended that his testimony was restricted to the latter. [Richards, et al. v. Griffin, 5 Ala. Rep. 195.]

In Bennett v. Armistead, use, &c. 3 Ala. Rep. 507, it was decided that the defendant could not be examined as a witness under the act of 1839, (cited above,) that his only privilege was to deny on oath the truth of the plaintiff’s testimony, and thus exclude it from the jury. See also, Ivy v. Pierce, use, &c. 5 Ala. Rep. 374; Anderson v. Collins, 6 Id. 783.

In the case at bar, it appears that the defendant was sworn generally, and gave evidence to the jury, notwithstanding the plaintiff objected; this was an irregularity which affects thé judgment in question.

The note addressed by the defendant to the plaintiff, is a demand of the gin, or fifty dollars, and informing the plaintiff, that if neither of the alternatives are complied with, then they would “ have to settle the matter in some other way.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.