Wisconsin Supreme Court July 15, 1845 (McGoon v. Irvin)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-07-1845

Dunn, C. J.

This was an action of trespass on the case on promises, brought by Irvin, plaintiff below, against McQ-oon, defendant, in the district court of Iowa county, and tried on change of v.enue, in the district court of Dane county.

The plaintiff in error, McQoon, assigns the following errors to the decisions and rulings of the district court of Dane county, on the trial of the cause, viz.:

1. In allowing the witness of plaintiff Irvin to answer the following question: £ £ What reply was made by said plaintiff to said witness in answer to such message?”

2. In allowing said witness to answer the following question: ££ What were the circumstances and ability of defendant to pay for supporting and educating his children ?”

3. In refusing to permit a witness on the part of defendant McQoon to answer the following question : ££ Was it or was it not a matter of notoriety in the neighborhood where the plaintiff lived, before the time of Ms marriage with Mrs. McG-oon, that defendant had made and was making efforts to recover possession of his children, in the custody of Mrs. McGfoon, the now wife of plaintiff, and that the children were kept by her from Mm ?”

4. In instructing the jury : “That the detention of the children by the wife of the defendant previous to her marriage with the plaintiff, whether such detention was tortious or not, can in no way affect the plaintiff in this form of action.”

5. In instructing the jury: “ That if they believe from the testimony that neither the defendant, nor any other person for him, ever made a demand of the children from the plaintiff, or warned the plaintiff against their maintenance, and that the defendant knew that Ms children were being maintained by the plaintiff, the defendant is liable for such maintenance.”

*5316.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.