Supreme Court of Louisiana May 15, 1845 (Campbell v. Nichols)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-05-1845

Morphy, J.

The petitioner claims a four-wheeled carriage, his property, now in the defendant’s possession, or $400, the value thereof. The defendant admitted that he had .the carriage in his possession, but averred that he purchased the same from Dubois and Kendig, dealers in carriages and horses, and that he paid for said carriage $150 to his vendors, whom he prayed to have cited in warranty. They came in, and averred that when Nichols applied to them for a carriage, there was one at their establishment answering the description of that claimed *17by the plaintiff, which had been sent there for sale by Hart, Butler & Co., of this city; that, at the instance and request of the defendant, this carriage was purchased for him, from Hart, Butler & Co. by Kendig, one of the firm of Dubois and Kendig, who acted in the transaction merely as his agent; and that, therefore, Dubois and Kendig were not his vendors, and cannot be made liable in warranty in this suit. There was a judgment below in favor of the plaintiff for the carriage sequestered, or, in default thereof, for its value, #150, with interest from the 23d of June, 1841, and a judgment in favor of the defendant against Dubois and Kendig, for a like sum and interest. The defendant, Nichols, appealed.

The evidence satisfactorily establishes the plaintiff’s ownership of the carriage. In May, 1840, an agent ofhis in Mississippi, consigned it to Hart, Butler & Co., commission merchants, at New Orleans, to be shipped to Texas, at such time as the plaintiff should direct. Hart, Butler & Co., contrary to their instructions, put the carriage into the hands of Dubois and Kendig for sale. The latter sold it to the defendant for #150, but did not represent themselves to him as the agents of Hart, Butler & Co.

It is clear the defendant acquired no right to the property in dispute, his vendors having none themselves, nor any authority to convey any. Hart, Butler & Co.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.