Supreme Court of Louisiana June 15, 1845 (Wellington v. Merchants' Insurance)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-06-1845
Bullard, J.
The plaintiffs sue upon a policy of insurance against fire, taken out by A. & G-. H. Wellington & Co. on their stock of goods, consisting of a general assortment of groceries, oils, liquors, &c., being either on own account, on commission, or held in trust, contained in a brick store occupied by the assured, sitüated Nó. 44 New Levée street, Second Municipality. They allege a loss by fire to the amount of $25,000, of which they gave due notice, and exhibited proper preliminary proof, and they sue for the amount insured -by the defendants, to wit, $7,500.
The defendants admit that they subscribed the policy, but they deny all the other allegations in the petition. They say especially that, even if the said plaintiffs were entitled to any relief under and by virtue of the policy, which they deny, yet such right would have .been forfeitéd by reason of this, which they specially aver, to wit, that the said plaintiffs have been guilty of fraud in demanding of this company an amount far beyond any loss or damage actually sustained by the said plaintiffs; and that said excessive demand and over estimate were made knowingly, and with intent to defraud the defendants. They aver that the conduct of the plaintiffs both before and since the alleged conflagration was fraudulent. They say also that if the respondents should be condemned at all, they should receive the benefit of the fact of any other -insurance having been effected on said property, if any there were. They deny the perform-*223anee of all and singular the conditions of the policy, and the ■verity of the representations therein contained.
■The plaintiffs recovered in the court below the amount demanded, and the defendants appealed.
Under the pleadings, and all the circumstances disclosed in 'this case, the judge of the Commercial Court gave judgment for the plaintiffs with evident hesitancy and reluctance ; and this, .
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit