New York Supreme Court November 13, 1848 (People ex rel. Moore v. Mayor of New York)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-11-1848
By the Court, Strong, P. J.
The principal, and only material objections to the proceedings of the defendants in this matter raised by the relator are, 1st. That the corporation removed the commissioners of estimate and assessment first appointed, and substituted others in their place; and 2d. That a contract for the work was executed, and operations were commenced, before the estimate of the expense required by the statute had been made. A preliminary objection was raised by the defendants, that the relator is not entitled to any remedy by certiorari.
I will consider the preliminary objection first. There can be no doubt that a certiorari will lie to review the judicial acts of municipal corporations. That was admitted in the case of Mount Morris Square, (2 Hill, 14,) cited by the defendants’ counsel, and is in conformity with the decisions of the late supreme court in several antecedent cases. (Elmendorf v. The Mayor, &c. of New- York, 25 Wend. R. 693 ; Le Roy v. the same defendants, 20 John. R. 430.) The authorities are equally clear that if the act complained of is simply ministerial.| it cannot ordinarily be reviewed on certiorari. Such was the ordinance of the common council for the construction of the sewer in question. That was a simple exercise of their ministerial, or if I may use the expression, legislative power. That, if authorized by their charter, which it clearly was, resolved itself into a question of expediency, solely for their consideration, and which cannot be reviewed here. But although the ordinance itself cannot, I think, be annulled by this court, yet it is competent for us, in a proper case, to vacate the estimate and assessment of the common council in affirming those proceedings; as they then acted in a judicial capacity. That may be, although they do not constitute an ordinary judicial tribunal. It is sufficient if they are invested by the legislature with power to decide on the property or rights of the citizen.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit