High Court of Chancery of Maryland December 15, 1848 (Small v. Owings)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-12-1848

The Chancellor :

With regard to the contract of the 8th of July, 1844, as set out in the receipt of that date, I do not deem it necessary to express any opinion, as it is manifest, that that contract, whatever its character may have been — whether obtained by false and fraudulent representations or not — has been merged in the subsequent agreement of July, 1845 ; which subsequent agreement alone, this bill seeks to enforce. And the question, therefore, is, whether the complainants háve made out a case which entitles them to the aid of this court in compelling the specific performance, by the defendant Owings, of this latter agreement.

It is urged by the complainants’ counsel, that the defendant, Owings, cannot protect herself under the plea of the statute of *366frauds, because, in her answer, in which reliance is placed upon the statute, it is levelled, not at the agreement which the bill seeks to enforce, but at the authority of the agent, Turn-bull, to make that agreement; and as the cases show that the authority of the agent need not be in writing, the statute has no application to the case.

It is not, however, I think, altogether clear, that in a case like the present, the defendant was bound to insist upon the statute of frauds at all. The answer certainly denies the authority of Turnbull, to make any agreement for the defendant, and, therefore, denies that any agreement binding upon her was made; and under such circumstances, it is by no means certain, that she is not entitled to the benefit of the statute of frauds, without pleading it. In the case of the Ontario Bank vs. Root, 3 Paige, 478, it was decided, that where the complainant sets up an agreement in his bill, which would be invalid by the statute of frauds, unless in writing, and the defendant by his answer denies the agreement, it is not hécésSary for him to insist upon the statute as a bar, but the complainant at the hearing must establish the agreement by written evidence.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.