Court of Appeals of Kentucky June 14, 1848 (Payne v. Payne's)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-06-1848

J’ddqe Simpson

delivered the opinion of the Court.

This was a motion to quash an execution, made by the defendant in the execution. Notice of the motion was given to the plaintiff, but the grounds upon which it was made were not set forth in the notice. When a party in a motion of this kind, intends to rely upon extrinsic matters not apparent upon the record, he is required to give notice to the opposite party. The object ■of this requisition is to enable the defendant in the motion, by being apprised of the matters relied upon by the plaintiff, to prepare his defence. To obtain this object, a specification in the notice of the grounds upon which the motion is based, is necessary; and the plaintiff, upon the trial, cannot introduce any evidence but that which is appropriate in support of the grounds thus specified.

The plaintiff in this motion, relies mainly upon the fact, that more than twenty years had elapsed after an execution issued on the judgment, before the issuing of the execution which he moved to quash. It appears that several executions having issued upon the judgment, but a small portion of which was made, and some of the executions having been returned, no property found out of which the balance could be made, a period of more than twenty years was permitted to elapse before another execution was sued out on the judgment. It is well settled, that where an execution has issued on a judgment within a year and a day after its rendition, and the return of the execution shows that it was not satisfied, another execution may issue at any subsequent period, without a scire facias. Upon this principle there was no impropriety in suing out the execution in this case, although twenty years had elapsed since the previous one had issued, There was no error, there*392fore, on the face of the record, which authorized the «execution to be quashed for this cause.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.