Mississippi Supreme Court January 15, 1849 (Dowell v. Brown)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-01-1849

Mr. Chief Justice Sharkey

delivered the opinion of the court.

The defendants in error sued on two promissory notes made by the plaintiff in error; one for $500, which was payable to S. S. Prentiss or order, and the other for $63, payable to George Montgomery. The first note was transferred by delivery only, but some time after the suit was brought it was indorsed. It is, however, declared on as having been “ indorsed and transferred to the plaintiffs.” If a note be payable to order, the legal title passes only by indorsement. Cohea’s Ex’rs v. Bacon, Jan. Term, 1849, [12 S. & M. 516.] If it be payable t® bearer, the legal title passes by delivery. And the holder cannot sue in his own name, on a note payable to order, without an indorsement. The subsequent indorsement does not cure the defect in the manner of declaring. The plaintiff must have a legal right of action at the *47time he brings the suit; and the proof must show such a right as he has declared on, in him, at the time he commences his suit. These plaintiffs were not indorsees at the time they sued as such, and consequently fail in proving a cause of action as laid.

But the declaration contains also a count for money had and received, and it is insisted that the note was admissible under this count. About this point we have had more difficulty. The admissibility of promissory notes and bills of exchange under the money counts, has given rise to much judicial discussion. Some of the English cases have held that the right to give them in evidence under the money counts was confined to the payee, and did not extend to indorsees. Waynam v. Bend, 1 Campbell, 175; Bentley v. Northhouse, 2 Ry. & Moo. 66. But by many other, decisions, both in England and this country, this right has been extended to the indorsee of a note or bill payable to order, and to the bearer of a bill or note payable to bearer.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.