New York Court of Appeals April 5, 1850 (Allen v. . De Witt)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-04-1850

Gardiner, J.

The question presented by this cause is, whether the power given to the executors to sell the real estate of the testator, was well executed by the conveyance to Hubbell.

The general rule is, “ that to the due execution of a power, there must be a substantial compliance with every condition required to precede or accompany its exercise.”

(Chance on Powers,

172, § 454; 1

R. S.

737, § 121.) The condition in this will is, that

after

the debts of the testator shall have been paid, the

avails

of his property should .be equally divided between his children. By

avails

I understand cash, or securities,

*279

the representatives of money. The debts of the testator were not paid at the time of the conveyance to Hubbell.

The argument in support of the sale is, that it was in effect a division of the avails, and a sotting apart this parcel of land, considered as cash, to the’ use of Hubbell in right of his wife, in part satisfaction of her claim as one of the children of the testator, to an undivided fourth part of the proceeds of her father’s estate.

There are two objections to this view of the case. 1st. The execution differs from the power in this, that the sale to Hub-bell was

before,

while the testator declares that the division of the “ avails” shall be

after

the debts were paid. In

Dike

v.

Rich, (Cro. Car.

335,) the power was to sell all the tenements, or so much as with the goods were

sufficient

to pay debts, &c. It was held not only that there

must be a deficiency,

but that a sale could only be made to the

extent

of it. Here the debts must be

paid

before the residue of the

“

avails” can be divided. 2d. The power requires an

absolute

sale, for a consideration fixed by agreement between the executor and the vendee, which was to constitute part of the proceeds or avails of the estate, and as such to be capable of being applied in payment of debts, or of forming a fund for the maintenance of the family, and of ultimate division among the heirs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.