Supreme Court of North Carolina December 5, 1850 (Currie v. . Swindall)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-12-1850

PearsqN, J.

There is error in the refusal to give the instruction prayed for, and in the manner in which the case was left to the jury.

The instruction concedes, that the plaintiff is entitled to recover, if the person accused surrendered himself, in consequence of either force or persuasion used by the plaintiff; but it asserts, that if the man surrendered himself of his own accord, the plaintiff is not entitled to recover. There can be no question of the truth of the proposition asserted; for, if the man surrendered himself of

*364

his own accord, without any force or persuasion on the part of the plaintiff, then he has not performed the ser* vices for which the reward was offered. Indeed, his Honor does not deny the proposition, but refuses “togive the instruction and after reciting what the defendant had conceded, “that it was not necessary for the plaintiff to have brought the man to jail by force, but if he had induced him lo come to jail by persuasion and promises of assistance, it would be the same as if he had used force,” he proceeds to instruct the jury, “that the only evidence, how the man got in jail, was the testimony of the jailor, and they must decide upon that, whether the plaintiff had brought and put him in jail and puts his refusal to instruct the jury, as prayed for, on the ground, that there was no evidence to raise the question.

There is error in thus narrowing down the case, and, in effect, deciding it. The man is in jail — he was induced to come either by force or persuasion used by the plaintiff, or he came of his own accord. There is no evidence, that he came of his own

accord

— ergo, he came by force or persuasion used by the plaintiff.

There is no evidence that the plaintiff had used force to apprehend the man.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.