New York Supreme Court February 18, 1850 (Mier v. Cartledge)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-02-1850
By the Court, Edmonds, P. J.
The power of the court to strike out a plea as false is not derived from the code; nor is it regulated or touched by it. It is a power which has been exercised for good reasons, as mentioned by the court in the case of Broome Co. Bank v. Lewis, (18 Wend. 565.) It never was applied to the general issue; because under the former practice a defendant had a right, always, to put the plaintiff to the proof of his demand, whether he had any pretence for doing so or not, and that was done by pleading the general issue. If, how*76ever, the defendant did not put him to his proof, that is, did not plead the general issue, but pleaded some other matter, without the general issue, such plea might be stricken out as false, though the only plea in the case, and thereby the plaintiif be entitled to sign judgment, without proving his demand. Such was the case of Richley v. Proone, (1 Barn. & Cress. 286.) That it was the only plea interposed, was of no consequence. The rule was not founded on that; but solely on the ground that the defendant had a right, even without any pretence of a defence, to put the plaintiff to proof of his demand. Formerly, if a defendant did not avail himself of this right, but by the form of his plea chose to claim to have a defence, which on the motion to strike it out, he admitted he had not at all, it might be struck out; because there was no reason in justice or good sense why such a plea should stand; why the courts should be occupied with irrelevant matters and the plaintiff be delayed, perhaps mined, before he could enforce the collection of a just demand. (18 Wend. 567.) This is, as I understand it, the reason why the general issue was never struck out, under the old practice, as false.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit