New York Supreme Court May 6, 1850 (Wells v. Padgett)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-05-1850
By the Court, Mason, J.
In an action by a lady for a breach of promise of marriage, it is not necessary for the purpose of making out the mutual promises, which are requisite to support the action, to prove that the plaintiff, by words, consented to accept the defendant. The jury may infer such consent from the circumstances of her making no objections at the time, and from her receiving visits from the defendant as suitor, &c. It would be indelicate to expect that she should consent in words. •No doubt the jury must be satisfied that there were mutual promises. The jury have so found in this case, and I am of opinion that there is evidence from which they may be inferred. (Daniel v. Bowles, 2 Carr. & Payne, 553. 12 Eng. Com. Law, 258. 12 Petersd. Abr. 577.)
The only remaining question in this case, deserving consideration, is the exception to the judge’s charge. He charged the jury that if they found, from the evidence, that the defendant’s promise to marry the plaintiff was made with a view to seduce her, and then abandon her, and that the defendant by means of the engagement to marry her, had seduced her, the seduction, under such circumstances, would be in aggravation of the broken promise; and that the jury would be at liberty, on that account, to give an increased verdict. But if the defendant had seduced the plaintiff before the promise to marry, then the seduction would lessen the plaintiff’s claim to damages, and render it a mere nominal amount. I am satisfied, after a careful examination, that the question raised by the judge’s charge has not been settled by the courts of this state. There is at least no reported case that I have been able to find, determining the question. I find that the question, however, has been passed upon by several of the state courts of the union. Chief Justice Parsons said in the case of Paul v. Frazier, (3 Mass. Rep.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit