New York Supreme Court November 4, 1850 (La Farge v. Herter)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-11-1850
By the Court,
Allen, J.
The plaintiff moves for a new trial upon several exceptions taken at the trial, to the ruling and decision of the judge. I. The first exception upon which the plaintiff relies is to the admission of evidence that Dillenback was a surety for Herter in the note upon which the judgment, which is the foundation of this action, was recovered. The ground of the objection was that the suretiship was merged in the judgment, and that both defendants, by the recovery of the judgment, became principal debtors. And the counsel relies upon the decision of the court in this case, reported 3 Denio, 157, and Hubbell v. Carpenter, (2 Barb. S. C. Rep. 484.) It is not indispensable to the decision of this cause to decide this question. The decision at the circuit was not based upon the mere fact of suretiship and a dealing with the principal debtor *161to the prejudice of the surety. If it had been, the decision would have been clearly wrong, for the manifest reason that the dealing established by the evidence was with the knowledge and assent of the surety, which would take the case out of the rule, and the reason of the rule by which sureties are held to be discharged in such cases. (Story’s Eq. Jur.. §§ 324, 326. Tyson v. Cox, 1 Tur. & Russell, 395. Gahn v. Niemcewicz, 11 Wend. 317, 325. Greely v. Dow, 2 Met. 176. Combs v. Woolf, 8 Bing. 136. Rees v. Benington, 2 Ves. jun. 540.) The final decision of the cause was upon the whole case, and may be sustained upon the ground that the judgment was paid by the bond and mortgage of Herter.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit