Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court November 15, 1850 (Commonwealth v. Herrick)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-11-1850
Shaw, C. J.
This is a complaint against the defendant, charging the sale of spiritous liquors by retail, on the first of January, 1848. The prosecution was commenced by complaint before a justice of peace, afterwards brought to the court of common pleas by appeal, and upon conviction and motion in arrest of judgment, brought to this court by a report of the judge, under the Rev. Sts. c. 138, § 12.
The ground, on which the motion in arrest of judgment is founded, is, that the law, under which the prosecution was instituted and the case tried, has been repealed by the statute of 1850, c. 232, so that no judgment can now be passed. It is undoubtedly true, that to warrant a judgment in any criminal prosecution, the law making the act done an offence, and providing for its punishment, must be in force when the act is done, and the judgment rendered; and, therefore, if the law is repealed before judgment, without a saving clause, in respect to offences committed previously to its repeal, no judgment can be given. Commonwealth v. Kimball, 21 Pick. 373.
Is this case within that principle ? The statute relied upon, as having repealed the statute on which this complaint was founded, (St. 1850, c. 232,) certainly does not repeal the preexisting statute in terms; if it effects such repeal at all, it must be by implication, and because it is repugnant. The provision is, that the 47th chapter of the revised statutes is hereby amended by striking out11 spiritous,” and inserting the word “intoxicating,” in the several clauses prohibiting the retail sale of liquor. The second section has no application, and the third provides, that upon a third conviction a party may be required to enter into a recognizance, with a condition not to violate the law.
This section does not alter the penalty, upon a first or second conviction, but leaves the law in this respect unchanged.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit