Supreme Court of Vermont February 15, 1850 (Edson v. Town of Pawlet)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-02-1850
The opinion of the court was delivered by
Hall, J.
It is insisted, in behalf of the defendants, that the contract between the plaintiff and the town was a wagering contract, and for that reason should be held illegal and void. Since the case of Collamer v. Day, 2 Vt, 146, the doctrine has been considered as settled in this state, that all wagers are illegal, and that therefore the winning party to a wager will in no case be allowed to recover of the loser for the money or property won. If in this case the plaintiff is to be considered as suing for the recovery of a wager, there can be no doubt the defence should be held sufficient.
It may, perhaps, be difficult to give a legal definition of a wager. In ordinary acceptation, a wager is the placing of something valuable, belonging in part to each of two individuals, in such a position, that it is to become the sole property of one, upon the result of some unsettled question. Each of the parties risks something, which he may lose, and each may gain something, beyond what he risks. If he merely hazard the loss of something, without any expectation, in any event, of having more in return than he ventures, it would not seem to be a wager.
It does not appear to us, that the present was what can be properly termed a wagering contract. The plaintiff may be said to have risked his compensation upon the event of the pauper being found *294to have a legal settlement in Sandgate. But he was in no event to have move than he ventured ; the most he was to receive was a reasonable compensation for his services. It is merely a case, where a party performs a service, for which he is entitled to compensation, but which he agrees to relinquish upon the happening of some future event. It properly belongs to the class of “ no cure no pay cases,” upon the expediency of which we are not called upon to express an opinion; but which we find no ground for declaring to be illegal.
The case of Pawlet v. Sandgate, 19 Vt.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit