Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court March 15, 1850 (Parker v. May)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-03-1850

Shaw, C. J.

This is an information filed by the attorney of the commonwealth, for the county of Suffolk, on the equity side of the court, in the name and behalf of the commonwealth, at the relation of Daniel Weld, a member of the Hollis street church, and of the proprietors of the Hollis street meetinghouse. The suit is brought against Samuel May and Eleazer Nichols, deacons of the Hollis street church, John Pierpont late pastor of the church and society, and the New England bank and Atlantic bank of Boston.

At the opening of this hearing, it was objected, on the part of the respondents, that the suit could only be prosecuted by the public prosecutor personally; and that if it was rightly commenced by the attorney of the commonwealth for Suffolk, which they denied, he could only appear personally; and that the gentlemen, here conducting the cause as counsel for the relators, could not be heard. This objection was overruled, and upon reconsideration, I think rightfully. The authorities cited, I am satisfied, show that such a suit by the public prosecutor, in the name of the commonwealth, for establishing and sustaining charitable trusts, is, in truth as well as in form, a suit to protect public interests; and that it must be prosecuted with the sanction of the public prosecutor, whose duty it is to see that the public interests sustain no detriment, and to proceed in the prosecution or stay proceedings, as a just regard to these interests may require. It follows, therefore, that this proceeding is not to be considered as the suit of the relators; nor can the relators, of their own motion, or in their own names, take any step in the cause, or be heard as parties. Courts of equity have also suggested, and the suggestion is certainly entitled to great weight, upon the most obvious considerations of fitness and propriety, that the attorney-general or public prosecutor ought not to appear as counsel for adverse parties in such a suit.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.