Court of Appeals of Kentucky December 10, 1850 (Cecil v. Johnson)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-12-1850

Judge Simpson

delivered the opinion, of the Court.

The only question of importance in this case is, the one in relation to the admissability as evidence of the judgment in an action of ejectment, in which Cecil’s heirs were the lessors of the plaintiff, and Johnson was *36the defendant, the judgment having been rendered in favor of the latter.

A judgment in ejectment in behalf of heirs held to be competent evidence in an action of trespass against the widow of the decedent in behalf of the heirs who claim the land.

It has been repeatedly decided by this Court, that a judgment in an action of ejectment, that is not embraced by the act of 1825, (1. Stat. Law 586,) is no bar to a subsequent action of the same kind, between the same parties for the same land. In this case both parties claim under the same title, and do not come within the operation of that Statute.

This it is true, is an action of trespass quare clausum fregit, brought by Johnson for a trespass alleged to have been committed upon the land after the termination of the action of ejectment in his favor. But if the judgment in ejectment would' not be conclusive in another action of ejectment brought by Cecil’s heirs against Johnson for the land, it would follow as a necessary consequence, that it could not legitimately have that effect in an action of trespass between the parties involving the same question.

But although the judgment in ejectment is not conclusive evidence upon the question of title, it is evidence to some extent, in a subsequent action, where the parties are substantially the same, and 'the same matter is involved in the issue between them. But not being conclusive, it can only be regarded as prima facie evidence, liable to be counter-balanced and controlled by the other testimony in the cause, if it be sufficiently satisfactory to produce that result.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.