Court of Appeals of South Carolina May 15, 1850 (State v. Floyd)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-05-1850
Curia, per Withers, J.
The point raised by the first ground of appeal, we hold to have been definitely settled, that is to say, Noah Harmon was a competent witness in this cáse.
The question presented by the second ground for a new trial, which complains that the defendant was arraigned and tried for a felony, under statute, whereas the oifence was no more than misdemeanor, is not properly a question on the case; for it was no matter of objection on the circuit. The defendant has, certainly, taken no prejudice thereby; quite the contrary.
The material legal questions arising in the case we take to be:
1. Was the alteration of the receipt imputed to the defendant, the oifence of forgery under our statute law?
2. Was the offence of such forgery, or of uttering and publishing the instrument knowing it to be forged, legally set forth in the indictment?
The receipt was in these words:
“Received, January 29th, 1848, of Washington Floyd, twenty-one dollars and 50 cents, for work done in 1847, in full up to date. (Signed.) Noah Harmon.”
The Jury have found that, after the receipt was executed, the defendant deceitfully and fraudulently struck out the word “ part,” and wrote, in lieu of it, the words “ full up to date.”
• The first question is, was this forgery? — or does it import that the defendant did “falsely make, forge, and counterfeit” an acquittance or receipt for money, with intent to defraud Noah Harmon? The equivalent question is, was the alteration, above specified, falsely making and forging the receipt set forth ?
Our statute of 1736, embracing the description of papers in question, is borrowed from 2 Geo. 2, ch. 25, and it does not use the word “alter” in relation to acquittances or *64receipts. That word is introduced in imitation of another British statute, in relation to other descriptions of writings.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit