Supreme Court of the United States April 26, 1850 (Wilson v. Simpson)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-04-1850

Mr. Justice WAYNI ¡

delivered the opinion of the court.

In the argument of this case, the counsel for the appellant put his right to the relief sought by his bill upon two points. We will consider them in the order in which they were presented. -

The appellant’s first point is, that the title and right of the defendants to use the Woodworth invention are taken from them by the fraud and artifice of Emmons, Tyack, Toogood, and Halstead, in procuring from Woodworth and Strong the deed of the 28th of December, 1829. (Rec. 51, 52.)

The fraud alleged in the bill is, that Emmons, having pirated Woodworth’s invention, contrived, by misrepresentation, to get a patent for the same, and, in conjunction with Toogood, Hal-stead, and Tyack, falsely and fraudulently represented to Woodworth, and to Strong, his- assignee, that Emmons was the first inventor, of the planing-machine, for which Wood-worth had received the first patent’; and that Woodworth and Strong, regarding it possible that such might be the fact,, not suspe.cting any fraudulent device, and fearing, notwithstanding Woodworth knew the invention to be his own, it might be established against him, executed the agreement of the 28th of November, 1829, for which no other consideration was received than Emmons’s pirated patent.

The case is before us upon the original bill, and as it was afterwards amended, upon answers and replication. The defendants traverse this allegation of- fraud, as fully as persons so situated can do, and deny any notice or knowledge about it, when they became the assignees of the invention- for a valúa

*121

ble consideration. The complainant, then, must establish his charge by proofs. We think it has not been done.

The proof relied upon is, that, though Emmons received a. patent for what he claimed to be his invention, it was subsequently proved to be identical with the principle of Wood-worth’s machine, and had been pirated from it.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.