Texas Supreme Court July 1, 1851 (Howard v. Perry)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-07-1851

Wheeler, J.

A question of the admissibility of evidence is presented, which may be disposed of before proceeding to consider the merits of the case.

It is objected to the admissibility in evidence of the copy of the defendant’s certificate and field notes from the General Land Office, that they are attested by the chief clerk, and not by the commissioner.

The act of the 14th of December, 1837, section 3, (Hart. Dig., art. 1839.) provides that, in the absence of the Commissioner of the General Land Office, or in case of his inability to attend to the duties of his office, the chief clerk shall perform all the duties appertaining to the office. The act of 1S46, (Hart. Dig., art. 2175.) further provides that, “ in case of the sickness, death, or resignation of the Commissioner of the General Land Office, it shall be lawful for the chief clerk to act, and perform all the duties required of said commissioner.” We regard the latter of these statutes as merely cumulative ; consequently, in any event contemplated by either statute, it is competent for tlie chief clerk to perform the duties appertaining to the office of commissioner. And where he has acted in this capacity, the presumption is that some one of the contingencies existed on the happening of which he was authorized to act. The objection to the admissibility of tlie evidence, therefore, is not tenable. (Hart. Dig., art. 1841.)

The determination of the merits of the case requires a consideration of the relative strength of the respective titles of the plaintiffs and defendant. For it is evident that the joint resolutions gave a title to the heirs of Hibbins from their date, which will be good as against the defendant, if he liad not a right to the land previously acquired.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.