Supreme Judicial Court of Maine July 1, 1851 (Sturtevant v. Merrill)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-07-1851

Tenney, J.

— The verdict in this case was in favor of McGregor, and against the other defendant, who took exceptions to the instructions given to the jury, and also to the refusal to give those requested.

By the statute, chap. 30, sec. 6, if a person is injured in his lands by certain descriptions of domestic animals, named, he may recover his damages in an action of trespass, against the owner of the beasts, unless they were lawfully on the adjoining lands, and escaped therefrom in consequence of the neglect *65of the person, who had suffered the damage, to maintain his part of the partition fence. The neglect, which is made a bar to a recovery in an action of trespass of this kind, can arise only from a division, which imposes the obligation upon the party injured to build and maintain upon a certain well defined portion of the line a legal fence. If no division, such as the statute recognizes has been made, the omission is not to be treated as the fault of one party, more than that of the other. And if no fence is built thereon, it may be, because the parties have agreed to occupy and improve their several lands adjoining each other in common; or because they intend to hold according to their rights at common law. The latter may be the legal presumption, in the absence of all evidence upon the question. If a fence is built and maintained upon the line between the occupants of contiguous lands, without a valid division, according to law, partly by one and partly by the other, no statute rights or responsibilities will result therefrom.

In the case at bar, there being no division, the parties were in the enjoyment of no rights under the statute, in their occupation. There is no evidence of any agreement or understanding that the lands were intended to be occupied in common.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.