Supreme Court of Connecticut June 15, 1851 (Peck v. Whiting)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-06-1851

Hinman, J.

The defendant attached the goods in question, as the property of John D. & Mark Leavenworth. He found them at the store where said Leavenworths had been doing business, in the actual possession, for the time, of Mark Leavenworth; and the question is, whether they can be held, by the attaching creditor, against the plaintiffs, who claim them under a previous assignment, pursuant to the statute of 1828, for the benefit of the Leavenworths' creditors.

The case turns upon the question whether there was any legal reason for the possession, retained, by one of the assignors, after the assignment. The plaintiffs claim, that the case of an assignment, for the benefit of creditors, under the statute, forms an exception to the rule, requiring a change of possession, in order to prevent a transfer of personal property from being deemed fraudulent. That there is, in this respect, a very marked distinction between an assignment for benefit of creditors, and an ordinary sale inter partes, there can be no doubt. Such a distinction was fully established, in the case of Osborne v. Tuller, 14 Conn. R. 529. *211and again recognised, in the case of Strong v. Carrier, 17 Conn. R. 319. In those cases, it was held, that the legal presumption of fraud, arising from the continued possession of the assignor, was repelled, by proof, that the requirements of the statute had been complied with. The reason of those decisions was, that the assignee, under the statute, having complied with its terms, had so made himself responsible to the general creditors, that they could not be defrauded, by any disposition he might choose to make of the property. We are well satisfied with those decisions, and do not intend to qualify them, in the least; but we think it very clear, that this case does not fall within them.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.