Supreme Court of Louisiana June 15, 1852 (Nelder v. Testamentary Executors of Macarty)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-06-1852
By the court:
Eustis, C. J.
This appeal is taken from a judgment of the court of the Fifth District of New Orleans, by which the last will and testament of the late Louis B. Macarty was annulled, so far as relates to the plaintiff’s interest in the succession; and they were adjudged to recover their hereditary portion, to wit, one-fourth of the effects thereof.
The ground on which the judgment appealed from is based, is a question of fact; and the conclusions of the district judge, after recapitulating the evidence and commenting on it with great care, are thus given:
“In this conflict of the testimony of the witnesses to the will, and failure of the recollection of the notary who received it, upon a point which is left doubtful by the phraseology of the will, a point which is held to be essential to the validity of a nuncupative will by authentic act, as we have seen above, it is my duty to pronounce as not proved, that the will in question was dictated by the testator to the notary, in the presence of the witnesses; and, for want of this formality, that the said will is invalid as regards the plaintiffs.”
There were other demands against different parties, cumulated in the plaintiff’s petition independant of the validity of the will, but the district judge confined his decision to this single point, reserving all other matters for further adjudication.
The nuncupative will of the testator, L. B. Macarty, was by public act. To give validity to this class of instruments, the law requires that it be received by a notary public, in the presence of three witnesses residing in the place where the will is made, or five non-resident witnesses. It must be dictated by the testator, and written by the notary as it is dictated. It must then be read to the testator, in the presence of the witnesses. Express mention must be made of the whole, observing that all these formalities must be fulfilled at one time, without interruption and without turning aside to other acts.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit